Best angle vs best rate — excess thrust vs excess power
Climbing and Descending — Theory Part 1: Climbing
Factors affecting climb performance
What factors might affect our climb performance?
Engine power — more power = better climb rate; engine power reduces with altitude
Airspeed — only VY gives maximum rate of climb; too fast or too slow reduces climb rate
Weight — heavier aeroplane = more mass means greater thrust required for same climb = reduced climb rate
Wind — headwind improves best-angle performance (more altitude per ground distance); no effect on best rate
Density altitude — hot, high, humid conditions reduce both engine and aerodynamic performance
Monitor engine temperatures during a prolonged climb — the engine is working harder than in cruise.
Climbing and Descending — Theory Part 1: Climbing
Recap
Climbing and Descending — Theory Part 1: Climbing
Part 1 Recap — Climbing
Can you answer each of these?
Which of the four forces change and which remain the same when transitioning from level flight to a climb entry?
What is the climb entry sequence? (three letters)
What is the level-off sequence, and why does the order differ from the entry?
Name three types of climbs — what speed and attitude does each use?
When would you choose VX over VY?
Name two factors that reduce climb performance (e.g. on a hot day or at high altitude)
Climbing and Descending — Theory Part 1: Climbing
Arrival
Building directly on straight and level flight from Lesson 2.
The student knows the performance formula; this session applies it to gaining altitude.
Key theme: set the attitude and power, let the performance follow — same as always.
Part 1 covers the climbing side. Part 2 will cover descents and instrument indications.
Return to these at the recap. Ask the student to answer each from memory before revealing.
Click Direct-To to advance to The Four Forces in the Climb.
Demonstrate:
- 60% with 4 degrees,
- 70% with 2.5 degrees,
- 90% with 1.5 degree
Note the speed for each.
Keep this simple. The key insight: climbing requires excess thrust.
Try:
- 100% with 8 degrees - around 500 ft/min
Best rate of climb:
- 100% with 12 degrees is 650 ft/min @ 90 knots = 650 / (90 * 6000 / 60) = 7.2% climb
Best angle of climb example:
- 100% with 15 degrees is 600 ft/min @ 78 knots = 600 / (78 * 100) = 7.7% climb
That's why we use full power for VX and VY.
Reinforce: the most common student error is trying to correct an incorrect attitude by chasing the airspeed. Set the attitude, let the speed stabilise, then make small adjustments.
Examples:
- 100% with 8 degrees - around 500 ft/min @ 100kts
Best rate of climb:
- 100% with 12 degrees is 650 ft/min @ 90 knots = 650 / (90 * 6000 / 60) = 7.2% climb
Best angle of climb example:
- 100% with 15 degrees is 600 ft/min @ 78 knots = 600 / (78 * 100) = 7.7% climb
Click Direct-To to advance to Climb Entry and Exit.
Set:
- Throttle to 40%
Ask, at what point in a car, would you add power?
- Right before the bottom of the hill.
Right before our attitude changes due to the hill.
**Power**, Attitude, Trim.
PAT gets you into the climb; ALAP keeps you there. Three of the four steps keep eyes outside — that's the point. Only Performance requires a glance at the instruments. Repeat the cycle continuously throughout the climb.
APT for level-off. The sequence differs from climb entry (PAT) because we need the speed to build before reducing power — lowering the nose alone won't accelerate the aeroplane quickly enough if power is pulled at the same time.
Click Direct-To to advance to Types of Climb.
Use the model aeroplane or a whiteboard diagram to show the nose attitude difference between all three.
Demo script — left chart first, then right:
- Before touching anything, ask: why do best angle and best rate happen at two *different* speeds?
- Left chart: drag the cursor to where the green gap between thrust available and thrust required is widest — it snaps at VX. Excess *thrust* is what pulls us up most steeply per metre travelled: best **angle**.
- Right chart: drag to where the gap between power available and power required is widest — it snaps at VY. Excess *power* is height gained per minute: best **rate**.
- Have the student predict before revealing: is VX slower or faster than VY? (Slower — the thrust surplus peaks earlier than the power surplus, and the charts show why.)
- Drag slower than VX and watch the excess shrink again — we'll return to this region ("behind the curve") in the stalling lesson.
The model is generic but calibrated (vs=43, cruise-kts=148) so VX and VY land on the Warrior's 63 and 75 KIAS from the previous slide.
Introduce density altitude gently. The key takeaway: on a hot summer day, the aeroplane will not climb as well as the book figures suggest. The POH performance charts assume standard conditions.
Click Direct-To to advance to the recap.
Ask one at a time; let the student answer before revealing. End positively — this content is the foundation for the descent session that follows.